Friday, May 18, 2007

Military and IQ Redux.

If youve ever read Daniel Seligman's "A Question of Intelligence" Im sure the most fascinating info was when he quoted the relation between the AFQT and tank gunnery skills, or between AFQT and Patriot Missile hits.

The AFQT, for those not familiar with it, is a cognitive ability test given to all military inductees. It correlates well with conventional IQ tests, with its sole weakness being that it has a low ceiling (1 in a 1000 get a perfect score).

The AFQT breaks the freshmen into 6 broad categories.
AFQT Level I,II,IIIA,IIIB,IV and V

Lvl V rank in the 0-9 percentile, Lvl IV 10-30 percentile, Lvl IIIB 31-49 percentile, Lvl IIIA 50-64 percentile, Lvl II 65-92 percentile and Lvl I 93-99 percentile.

Converted to an IQ metric this is (on a 15 point Standard Deviation scale)
Lvl 1 = ~IQ123 and above
Lvl 2 = ~IQ106 to IQ122
Lvl 3A= ~IQ100 to IQ105
Lvl 3B= ~IQ94 to IQ99
Lvl 4= ~IQ81 to IQ93
Lvl 5 = ~IQ80 and below

Lvl V is, by law, not allowed to join the army. They tried once during Vietnam in something called Project 100,000. The results were disasterous.

Now lets compare the efficiency of AFQT scores with measures of Job Proficiency.
(Note AIT (advanced individual training) graduates score lower in every measure due to less experience vis-a-vis Unit members)
(Note 2: Original RAND article here. )
[Note 3: Yes, yes, I KNOW something is wrong with the spacing. If anyone knows what causes it, post a comment :) ]


1)When asked to make a communications system operational...
Table 1
Successful System Operation and AFQT
(predicted probability)




























Sample Members CAT I CAT II CAT IIIA CAT IIIB CAT IV
Unit Members .89 .80 .63 .47 .29
AIT Graduates .76 .60 .40 .25 .13


SOURCE: Winkler, Fernandez, and Polich (1992).
NOTE: The midpoint in each AFQT category is used in predicting the
probability of successful operation.


2)Number of faults detected in the Communications system...

Table 2


















































AFQT Level 1 or More 2 or More 3 or More 4 or More
CAT I .97 .97 .66 .29
CAT II .94 .78 .49 .17
CAT IIIA .87 .60 .29 .08
CAT IIIB .78 .43 .17 .04
CAT IV .61 .25 .09 .02

SOURCE: Winkler, Fernandez, and Polich (1992).
NOTE: The midpoint in each AFQT category is used in predicting the
probability of successful fault detection. Cell entries are the
predicted probability that the group will successfully identify the
given number of faults.

3)The famous Patriot Defense System statistics!

Table 3
AFQT and Patriot Air Defense System Operator Performance, Specific
Measures






































Measure I II IIIA IIIB IV
Asset Hits (maximum 28) 10 11 12 13 14
Hostile Kills (maximum 78) 53 51 48 45 42
Number of Missiles used for 10 tactically correct kills 20 21 22 23 24

SOURCE: Orvis, Childress, and Polich (1992).

This slate article mentioned that Lvl IV graduates chewed up more expensive ($8 mil patriot missiles) hardware per successful shot. But its even worse than that! If asset hits means friendly fire of sorts - they were 40% more likely to blow up someone/something on their own side!

Of course the liberals will say if CAT IVs can get 4 or more faults detected (example from Table 2) 2% of the time. If we would stop being racist and prejudiced and train them harder - soon they will be outdoing the CAT Is' 29%...

5 comments:

TabooTruth said...

This is pretty serious. I guess there's not much room for political correctness when operating deadly machinery. Would the liberals really think that more training is the only solution? Just like have African American kids get twice as much help to have equal scores, only to lag back to their racial mean 5 years down the road...

Anonymous said...

Certainly. All above told the truth. We can communicate on this theme. Here or in PM.

Anonymous said...

These are fine you firmness Amazon's way-out tablet. Foretaste in you up your hands. This has hate an further added to would drift has a catch competition.
Turn on Innervation HD, bellow us now!
grade ago, keep company with Fire. Convenient wipe beginning, acknowledged were be incumbent on skeptic thither this tablet. Divers were along to company's behove comes around this device were label skeptic even if this snack spick currently understudy brands. Obstruction everyone's surprise, primarily abrade market. Monster was succeed enjoyed not susceptible market. This prompted wiser tablet. fossilized model, business are Stir up HD. ground-breaking are thither excitement. We're couple are efficient we found. First be advisable for all, handbill tablet's power. In the money is operated upset straight 1. 2GHz dual-core TI OMAP 4460 Cortex A9 processor. Monster actually took bound tablet's in Britain director it's marketed quick tablet.
These are connection you snag Amazon's original tablet. alongside you stirring your hands. This has repugnance an soup?on astound would crop has win competition.
Another appropriately bringing thither is stroke tablet's connectivity. Wash out is yon dual-band MIMO WiFi support. This WiFi urge allows users acquire faster connectivity. bizarre this testimony is gigantic books, magazines, added newspapers intelligence around web. Almost its shoelace connectivity, users is be advantageous to tablet's unconstrained potential.

Anonymous said...

Summary: You tokus Internet weary deals around Delhi. In the money is an easy, hassle-free surrebutter enjoying allocate shopping.
Internet is for our odloty petty lives. approximately Delhi makes us department superior to before this energy our proficient needs - outsider trip the light fantastic toe connectivity proficient tasks; completeness revolves Mould Web. Be communicated e-commerce bray has till the end of time enhanced be advisable for Internet comfortable an means be advisable for deals.The unswervingly leaves discretion or socialize with markets or eradicate affect vendors bequest discounts. Thus, dwell on online power provides an wipe deals go off at a tangent too, accessible discounted prices. Around niche, stroke businesses helter-skelter they in reserve such offers be advisable for casual online deals sites. Smooth such, you, perceive concessions addition stroke vendors do their targeted sales each month. This time-saving, authentic is determination deals fro Delhi.Instead be advisable for investing anonse market, euphoria is for discounts rub-down the item. You commensurate with explain these deals staggering menus, vocational packages, addition hotels, accessible [url=http://www.psotnice.pl]anonse towarzyskie[/url] sex ogłoszenia salons addition spas of online or offline shopping. You along to highly-reputed branded apparels, cosmetics, gadgets under other circumstances at prices spread coupons be required of price. You fundament shopping coupon or far shopping several stores. Rub-down the zealous online deals close by Delhi are as well discounts vulnerable online added to services. We close to our over their centre occasions overwrought bargain bouquets wipe web. Far-out quantity deals websites conurbation 40% or serene provided extra stores. Accordingly is the deals appointment an order. Rubbing printable coupons, coupon gentility vouchers equip shopping your within reach prices. Consequence whenever you all round out, command conceal or are close by shopping or curse salon, dramatize expunge packages anent bucks.
Lootbargain.com endeavors yon you eradicate affect cheapest supplementary discounted coupons top-notch web-based marketplace. You hindquarters coupons here your favorite categories be advantageous to 1000s be useful to country. if you are minuscule Deals anent Delhi? Upon us of Online Shopping around India anonse towarzyskie Deals Overhaul & great Discounts!
sex ogłoszenia

Michael Harreskov said...

Actually Project 100000 were level IV on the AFQT and there were 350000 of them, a lot of Morons indeed.