Saturday, December 1, 2007

Answer to the BrainTeaser (and a cool thought experiment).

Well,
A week has passed. I guess its time to post the answer.

Dissidentman got it right.

The Answer is: The heavier the object, the faster the fall

Question of course is why?

When I was younger in physics class, I, and all other pupils besides, found it extremely puzzling why two objects would fall at the same rate once air resistance was discounted. The classic experiment being sucking the air out of two identical jars, and dropping a metal ball and a feather in them and observing the same speed and acceleration.

But heavier things are harder to lift. It just seemed so counterintuitive. School being school, we never got a good answer as to why.

Lets use Reductio Ad Absurdum to answer the puzzle. And to why the standard answer is wrong.
Acceleration due to gravity of earth is taken as 9.8 meters per second. Lets approximate this to 10. So a rock of mass/weight 1kg accelerates towards the earth at 10 meters per second. Following textbook logic - a rock of weight 5kg also accelerates at 10 meters per second.

How about a rock of a million kilograms? Still 10 meters per second?
10 million kilograms?
50 million?

Still the same?

Okay. How about a rock the same mass/weight/size/shape etc etc of the Earth itself? Here we arrive at the reductio that helps us solve the puzzle.

Obviously Earth attracts things towards itself at an acceleration of 10 meters per second. But the "Clone Earth" falling towards Earth will also attract the Earth towards itself at an acceleration of 10 meters per second. So the total acceleration will be 20 meters per second.

But this blasts out of the water the theory that all objects drop towards the earth at the same rate!

If my reading of history is correct Johannes Kepler was the first person to define gravity as the mutual attraction of two objects towards each other.

So how does that apply to the 10 pound and 20 pound objects? Simple.

We need to take into account the weight of the earth as well as the weight of the object. Say for illustration the earth weighed 10 thousand pounds.

The first object weighing 10 pounds falls as a function of the weight of itself and the earth, aka 10,010 (ten thousand and ten) pounds. While the second object falls as a function of a weight of 10,020 (ten thousand and twenty) pounds or about 0.1% faster.

In reality though the earth doesnt weigh 10,000 pounds - but trillions of pounds. So the slightly faster fractional speed that the heavier object falls at is so small as to be unmeasurable.

Still. Its a pretty cool thought experiment.

18 comments:

DissidentMan said...

Don't I get a world cruise or something as a prize?

MensaRefugee said...

A years supply of Junk Mail good enough?

Johnson said...

Are the measurements really that insignificant? I figure if NASA is launching a gigantic ship or something than possibly they would have to redo their calculations, because precision is extremely important in space travel?

Mensarefugee said...

Johnson - Good point.
Depends on what level of precision is needed for the job of course.

I doubt the people at NASA (moon hoax aside) dont know this. But up to and perhaps including college - its not taught nor thought about.

Just another example of how the education system is based on rote learning rather than critical thinking - even in cognitively high octane fields such as Physics.

Anonymous said...

http://markonzo.edu So where it to find, ashley furniture price [url=http://jguru.com/guru/viewbio.jsp?EID=1536072]ashley furniture price[/url], 9198, allegiant air verdict [url=http://jguru.com/guru/viewbio.jsp?EID=1536075]allegiant air verdict[/url], yvkpjkc, pressure washers info [url=http://jguru.com/guru/viewbio.jsp?EID=1536078]pressure washers info[/url], wlqcx, dishnetwork blog [url=http://jguru.com/guru/viewbio.jsp?EID=1536080]dishnetwork blog[/url], anrkwp, adt security preview [url=http://jguru.com/guru/viewbio.jsp?EID=1536076]adt security preview[/url], nvxcpok,

Anonymous said...

http://lumerkoz.edu Great site. Keep doing., http://rc8forum.com/members/Buy-Protonix.aspx statues singaporean http://soundcloud.com/aldactone notably http://soundcloud.com/arimidex empires http://barborazychova.com/members/Buy-Nizoral.aspx workcover kasunic http://www.lovespeaks.org/profiles/blogs/buy-famciclovir assign

Cris said...

HI friends, this information is very interesting, I would like read more information about this topic, thanks for sharing. homes for sale in costa rica

niz said...

Hello .. firstly I would like to send greetings to all readers. After this, I recognize the content so interesting about this article. For me personally I liked all the information. I would like to know of cases like this more often. In my personal experience I might mention a book called Generic Viagra in this book that I mentioned have very interesting topics, and also you have much to do with the main theme of this article.

Anonymous said...

last week our class held a similar talk about this subject and you show something we have not covered yet, thanks.

- Laura

Anonymous said...

clomid ovidrel iui success | safe buy clomid online - can you buy clomid online, clomid faq

Anonymous said...

clomid early pregnancy symptoms | http://buy-clomid-in-usa.webs.com/#55378 - clomid 200 mg, how long does clomid take to work for men

Anonymous said...

bodybuilding clomid | [url=http://buycheapclomid.jimdo.com/#75701]100mg clomid[/url] - medication clomid, pikg period after clomid

Anonymous said...

taking clomid days 4 8 | http://buyclomidonline.webs.com/#45890 - how to buy clomid online, can clomid cause multiple births

Anonymous said...

clomid luteal phase defect | how long after clomid do you ovulate - buy clomid online australia, clomid yeast infection

Anonymous said...

clomid and male infertility | [url=http://orderclomid.jimdo.com/#4212]clomid and ovidrel success[/url] - cheap clomid no prescription, ipgi otc clomid

Anonymous said...

clomid blog | http://buyclomidcheap.webs.com/#57228 - buying clomid online safe, no ovulation on clomid

Anonymous said...

ovulation calculator clomid | clomid buy no prescription - where to buy clomid online safely, clomid complications

Anonymous said...

no ovulation on clomid | clomid drug - buy clomid online without prescription, clomid drug interactions